This for me is probably the turning point chapter. Once the Island is explored, we, as readers, get an answer to the question we’ve all been wondering – is there anyone else on this Island? (This was the fatal mistake that Harper’s Island made – it had an island so big, there could have been hundreds of killers hiding in the woods.)

While, in real life, the characters may not have scaled halfway down a cliff-face or wandered around a house with a tape measure, this is typical Agatha Christie’s way of recognising that you readers are armchair detectives.

There was a particular genre of mystery at the time known as “locked room” mysteries, where somebody would be murdered in a closed space that only certain people could get in or out of. The limited space required the murderers to be clever and limited everything to a fair number of suspects.

Well, now we have the dimensions of our locked room. For anyone thinking, “There could be a secret compartment somewhere”, we now know there isn’t a secret compartment. For those thinking, “The murderer could be hiding in a cave,” there isn’t a cave.

There’s no one else on this island except for the eight characters remaining, and – as the final scene in the Rogers’ room reminds us – two corpses.

I also liked the characterisation of the General – while he’s really gone mad, he’s actually clearly seen what’s going to happen to everyone, and he’s just waiting for him. In fact, if you thought they were going to find him murdered when they walked up to him and he was sitting still – you were meant to. Death is in the air everywhere.

See you tomorrow!

4 thoughts on “And Then There Were None – Chapter 8 (2 Dead; 8 Alive)

  1. The one thought that occurred to me after hearing them talk about Mr Rogers getting from the garden to upstairs without anybody noticing was the possibility of an identical twin. Maybe there are two Mr Rogers?

  2. Wow. That’s genius. I find myself trying to keep track of when characters are alone, but there seem to be large sections where we don’t know what is happening to certain characters!

  3. Of course for this to work the non-murderous twin would have to be oblivious to the murderous one’s presence (because, heck, he’s getting murdered too). Not sure if that could actually be made plausible. I guess we’ll see.

    Or, more likely, I’ll have a completely new mad theory for tomorrow’s chapter.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s