In many ways, the best thing to come out of this novel getting renamed as And Then There Were None is that it sets up a promise that – staggeringly – gets delivered in the final chapter.

We could believe, when it just came down to Vera and Lombard (why does he always get referred to by his last name, but she always gets referred to by her first?) that Lombard was it. Like Vera, we instantly see the wolf snarl and the cunning as the mark of a man who could cold-bloodedly pick off eight people one by one.

But then – the magnificent twist: the countdown goes down to zero. I remember I read this novel out loud to my sister when I was a teenager and at the time, none of us knew how it was going to end. And we hit this chapter, and it really just set my teenage brain reeling.

What on earth happened here? Did I really read what I thought I read?

For my money, it’s one of the greatest “What the…?” moments in storytelling history. The rug has been completely ripped out from under us. We know what we’ve witnessed – but we understand none of it.

And it is in that state of confusion, that Agatha Christie rolls out the Epilogue. I’ll see you tomorrow night for that one …

Advertisements

3 thoughts on “And Then There Were None (10 Dead; 0 Alive)

  1. Yes. Although, personally, the ‘And Then There Were None’ title meant that I never really believed that any of them were the murderer. I toyed with the notion briefly but, since Chapter One, I’ve been trying to work out how there could be either an extra person, a cycle of murders or some other solution.

    I don’t think I’ve come up with whatever AC’s going to pull out of her hat… so I’m still intrigued by that. But having never had the sense that one of the victims was the murderer, I don’t think I got quite the same ‘shock’ feeling from this chapter that you did, Matt.

    I am, however, very keen to be told what, exactly, happened. So I have the ‘totally baffled’ feeling down pat.

    For me, my overall satisfaction with this book is going to rest (probably predictably) on the remaining chapter/epilogue. If the explanation is clever and cool, I’ll be happy. If it’s not… well, I won’t be *unhappy*, because the process of reading it this way and pondering all the possibilities has been fun in itself. But I’ll be *less* happy.

  2. I can’t remember whether my shock was that I thought it would turn out to be one of the 10, or I just couldn’t work out how there could still be a killer on the island when they hadn’t found anybody. Either way, it’s one of those great fade to black moments where you think – “That *can’t* be the end.”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s