This is my second read-through of The Lord of the Rings. My first was just before the Peter Jackson films came out, and so I was racing through the books trying to finish each one before the film came out. If you’d asked me back then, I would have said that it was a bit like trying to read a fantasy adventure crossed with the King James Bible. Quite slow and ponderous. I mean, what was Tolkien doing? He’d take two pages to describe the landscape, then when the action came, it’d be over in two paragraphs!

But now that I’m back to reading it again, I’m a little bit more understanding of what he is doing. I also made a point of reading a couple of the Appendices first, rather than waiting till the end. If you approach his story armed with a knowledge of the history and background of the place, then his story comes alive – he really is giving us a zoomed-in view of a year in Middle Earth – an eventful year, but one that is part of a much broader sweep of history that has gone before it.

I think that’s what I missed the first time. I wanted action and adventure and for the story to get to the end. (And if you want that, the Jackson films have cleverly recrafted the story to provide all this.) However, what Tolkien provides is a much different experience. In real time, almost, day by day, he is recounting what happened to his characters and he will not be rushed. He is not interested in where the story is going, but the journey itself. Thus, the landscape and the history are important to what he is doing.

So if you take a deep breath and read it slowly, the richness of the world starts to come alive. (And I can’t help but wonder how strange this would have been to the original readers.) We’re kind of used to having hundreds of fantasy worlds, all with maps in the front of the books, strange names and their own rules. But I’m not sure how many of those existed when Lord of the Rings was first created.

The theme that seems to recur most often in the first book (apart from impending doom) is this feeling of ancient civilisations disappearing, to be replaced by new ones. Was this something Tolkien saw happening in England (a country where many ancient civilizations have settled and mixed together)? I don’t think we’ll ever know completely, and that’s probably okay. Will look forward to seeing how the other two volumes hold up.

4 ½ out of 5.


3 thoughts on “Book Review: The Fellowship of the Ring (JRR Tolkien)

  1. Ahem… Matthew, I believe you’re half a mark short… cough it up mate 😉

    Seriously, excellent review. And I find that even if you are seeking an action fix while you read it, that depth and richness of the history and languages that Tolkien created still comes through. It’s one of the things that makes LoTR unique among fantasy novels. That and the fact that as you rightly observed, everything else is derivative. And some of it feels horribly derivative too.

    Tolkien was quite disappointed by the war and all the changes that came about in England during the first half of last century. That shows in his writing, although he said that LoTR was most definitely *not* an allegory of what was happening in Europe at the time. If it was, Gandalf and Saurman would have taken the ring and used it and Hobbits would be in a hopeless situation no matter who won.


    1. Yeah, definitely, I wouldn’t really want to read spin-offs of this thing. (Though I am rather curious about The Last Ringbearer, which has recently been translated from Russian.) I think, now that I’m re-reading it, the loving descriptions of the landscape are actually a sort of lament to a time that is no longer. And maybe the day by day, blow by blow account of the hobbits’ travels is really a way for Tolkien to stay in that world as long as possible? Will get around to Two Towers soon, but I’m taking a break to read some other books in the interim.

  2. I just completed the second book “Two Towers”, it is equally entertaining. I would complete the last one in the LOTR series now. an amazing fantasy series.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s